Why Commercial Truck Insurance Costs Keep Rising

Commercial trucking

If you’re a trucking company owner or owner-operator, you’ve probably noticed your insurance premiums increasing year after year. Even companies with good driving records are feeling the impact.

So what’s causing commercial truck insurance rates to rise?

1. Larger Lawsuits Are Driving Up Costs

One of the biggest reasons is the increase in large trucking-related lawsuits, often called “nuclear verdicts.” These are jury awards or settlements exceeding $10 million, and some cases have reached tens or even hundreds of millions of dollars. When insurance companies pay larger claims, premiums increase across the industry.

2. FMCSA Safety Scores Matter More Than Ever

Insurance companies closely examine a carrier’s safety record before determining rates.

Items that can increase premiums include:

  • Poor vehicle maintenance scores
  • Frequent roadside inspection violations
  • Hours-of-service violations
  • Accidents and preventable crashes
  • High out-of-service percentages

The better your safety performance, the more attractive your company is to insurance carriers.

3. Truck Repairs Cost More

Modern trucks are loaded with technology, including cameras, sensors, collision mitigation systems and radar equipment.

Even minor accidents often require expensive repairs and recalibration of these systems. As repair costs increase, physical damage insurance costs increase as well.

4. Inflation Is Affecting Every Claim

Medical bills, labor rates, attorney fees and replacement parts have all increased significantly over the last several years. Every claim costs more to settle than it did in the past, which puts upward pressure on insurance premiums.

Why Proper Insurance Limits Are Critical

Many trucking companies carry only the minimum coverage required by law. While that may satisfy regulations, it may not be enough to protect the business after a serious accident.

A major crash involving multiple vehicles, severe injuries or a fatality can easily generate damages that exceed minimum policy limits.

When that happens, the trucking company can be responsible for costs that exceed the insurance coverage.

That’s why regularly reviewing liability limits is just as important as shopping for competitive rates.

Don’t Overlook Physical Damage Coverage

The cost to replace equipment has increased dramatically.

If your truck was insured for $120,000 several years ago but would cost $180,000 to replace today, you could face a significant shortfall after a total loss.

Reviewing truck values annually helps ensure your equipment is properly protected.

Final Thoughts

While you can’t control market conditions, you can control your safety culture, inspection programs and insurance strategy.

The goal isn’t simply finding the cheapest policy. The goal is to make sure your business has the protection it needs when the unexpected happens.

Contact Beehive Insurance and their truck insurance specialists to review your coverage today.

About the author

Brent Austin

Senior Account Executive

Brent joined the transportation team at Beehive Insurance in 2020 after several years in transportation-related support fields. Prior to joining Beehive, Brent worked in the Banking and Finance industries since 2004 and has been in Underwriting and Portfolio Management positions since 2008. His experience comes with companies such as Bank of Utah, Transportation Alliance Bank (TAB Bank), and England Carrier Services, a financial services division of England Logistics and CR England.
Brent strives to bring the best service possible to his clients through analyzing the client’s needs and making sure that they are not only getting the best coverage possible, but the best customer support as well. Through his experience in the Banking, Finance, and Transportation fields, Brent is able to bring value-add ideas as he consults with both small and large trucking companies.

Brent graduated from Utah State University (GO AGGIES!) and enjoys attending as many basketball and football games as he can. He is fluent in Spanish, a skill which has been very useful over the years in providing service to Spanish-speaking clients.

Brent tries to find humor in life, which leads him to watch a lot of Seinfeld and The Office. When at home, he tries to balance watching baseball and basketball with attending ballet recitals for his three girls. He is married to the love of his life, Natasha, who has a degree in Culinary Arts and is a private chef, so he is also the taste-tester for a lot of delicious recipes.


What is your favorite movie?

I really enjoy the entire Star Wars saga

Little known fact about you…

I am a book nerd, and would love to write a book one day

Words you live by…

“Balance doesn’t mean equal but finding the proper proportion of each”

Email Brent Austin Call (801) 743-7756

Related Posts

Request a Quote

Call 801-685-6860 or fill out the form below to get started or start a conversation.